BlogNewsletterPodcast
    Back to the blog
    Greensurance Needs Structure: Why Sustainable Insurance Begins with Standardised Data Flows
    10 November 2026Sasha Justmann10 min read
    BIPRO

    Greensurance Needs Structure: Why Sustainable Insurance Begins with Standardised Data Flows

    Data flows between customer, broker, and insurer as a lever for sustainability in BiPRO standardisation.

    Sustainability Is New on the BiPRO Agenda

    For twenty years, sustainability played no significant role in BiPRO standardisation. The standards governed how policy, document, and claims data flow between insurers and intermediaries – not whether a product carries environmental or social characteristics. That is currently changing: within BiPRO e.V., a working group is now tackling the question of how sustainability and greensurance can be mapped in the world of standards.

    Two main strands are emerging. The first concerns green IT: what contribution does standardised data transfer itself make – for example, because standardised, deterministic data streams render the computationally intensive AI interpretation of unstructured documents obsolete? The second concerns green insurance: how can sustainability characteristics of products, customer preferences, and processes be standardised so that they reach all connected distribution partners?

    In my article Green Interfaces, I discussed the core hypothesis that sustainability in insurance IT begins with data structure. What remained open was which data this actually involves. That is what this article is about – alongside an observation that quickly crystalised in the discussion: for classic sustainability reporting, standardised attributes help surprisingly little. So what actually needs to be standardised?

    Baseline Assessment: Heavy Regulation, Scarcity of Shared Data

    Regulators, rating agencies, and customers are increasingly asking for sustainability – yet outside of investment, there is hardly any shared, machine-readable data baseline.

    Regulation is intensifying, but remains fragmented: revised ESRS since 10 November 2026¹, a planned "Adaptation Underwriting KPI" for non-life business², the natural hazards extension to residential building insurance³, the UWG ban on unsubstantiated environmental claims since 27 September 2026⁴, and three new SFDR product categories⁵.

    Business lines are unevenly prepared. For funds and insurance-based investment products, the European ESG Template (EET) provides an established exchange standard⁶. In property and casualty (P&C) insurance, standardised sustainable policy features are still rare⁷; Franke und Bornberg has placed the topic on its watchlist in its contents rating due to a lack of robust criteria⁸. According to EIOPA, only 16 out of 46 manufacturers had classified sustainable non-life products at all⁹.

    The situation is similar among customers and distribution: high intent, low execution. 80 percent of customers want to consider at least one ESG criterion during their next policy purchase¹⁰, yet only a quarter know what sustainability means in insurance¹¹. In advisory meetings, the topic is missing in four out of five conversations¹².

    Where the Discussion Is Heading: Data Crossing Corporate Boundaries

    An insurer's sustainability report is an internal aggregation. It brings together premiums, investments, and emissions from its own systems – adding an extra attribute when transmitting data to the broker changes little about that. The obvious conclusion: standardisation creates value where sustainability data crosses corporate boundaries – between customer, intermediary, insurer, and service provider.

    Three such data flows particularly stand out, for example:

    • Preference matching in advice. The preference originates with the broker, the product feature with the insurer. Matching only works if both sides are standardised in the same format.
    • Prevention and geodata from application to rating. For the taxonomy's explicit approach, only premiums whose conditions include climate-related criteria with a pricing effect count¹³. Examples include the building's geocoordinates for flood and heavy rain zones, installed protective measures such as backwater valves or mobile flood defense, roof condition and construction type against storm and hail, or energy-efficiency retrofitting. All of this is captured at the point of sale – i.e. usually at the broker.
    • Lifecycle events in the portfolio. Sustainability is not a static state at contract conclusion. Renovations, an extension to include natural hazard cover, or the recategorisation of a fund alter the status of a policy – and the broker needs to know about it.

    Even reporting benefits indirectly from these flows. The PCAF standard calculates commercial insurance emissions via the ratio of premium to customer revenue – yet this revenue is not always captured during application intake¹⁴. Thus, the data gap in reporting often stems from a gap in the application – or at the latest when feeding back updated portfolio information.

    Lessons from Investments and Life Insurance

    Investments first created obligations and only later delivered the data. Since August 2022, intermediaries have been required to elicit sustainability preferences for insurance-based investment products – with a sober outcome:

    • Obligation before product classification: In an EY test, 95 percent of intermediaries skipped the assessment¹⁵. Without appropriately classified products in their tools, intermediaries lack the foundation for a systemic recommendation.
    • Overwhelmed by complexity: Taxonomy, SFDR, and PAI in a single query – customer willingness to engage dropped from 53 to 22 percent according to the AfW¹⁶; the association considers the query a failure¹⁷.
    • Correction via categories: Under SFDR 2.0, preferences under MiFID II and IDD are expected to be aligned with the new product categories – likely not before 2028¹⁸.

    In P&C insurance, there is no mandate to query preferences – in 30 analysed advisory sessions, no one asked about sustainability preferences¹². No supply without demand, no demand without supply.

    The lesson: P&C insurance can do it the other way round – first a shared data baseline, then advice and comparison, and regulation that builds on an existing standard.

    How Sustainability Could Be Standardised in the BiPRO Data Model

    The following ideas are conceptual models, not adopted standards. They follow a core principle: anyone creating a simple boolean field "sustainable" in their product or pricing model has already lost domain complexity. Sustainability is not a yes/no value, but a bundle of multiple features.

    An ESG Data Object Instead of Free Text

    Today, sustainability features in pricing, quote, and application processes are mostly mapped via free text, special agreements, or proprietary data extensions. That does not scale. A future standard could define a dedicated ESG data object referenced via standardised lists. It breaks down into three dimensions:

    • Circular economy: Repair over replacement, used parts, drying instead of replacement, ecological replacement values.
    • Climate: Physical risks and adaptation measures, i.e. geodata, risk categories, and prevention measures.
    • Social: Accessibility of the application journey, understandable policy terms, affordability in high-risk locations, non-discriminatory feature combinations.

    Two Levels: Category and Feature

    Investments show that advisory processes need simple classification, whereas pricing and proof require detail. The data object should therefore separate two levels: a high-level category for advice and comparison, and detailed features underneath. In life insurance, the category can align with SFDR 2.0 categories. For P&C insurance, there is no concrete specification yet – an open list could align with the taxonomy of the Versicherungsforen market monitor, which categorises non-life concepts into climate change adaptation, ecological added value, societal added value, and sustainable lifestyle¹⁹.

    Line-Specific Features in TAA Standards

    TAA standards 421 to 426 lend themselves to line-specific implementations:

    • Property (Standard 421 Personal Non-Life, Standard 426 Commercial): Energy efficiency rating, construction standard, PV systems, heat pumps, and energy storage as insured items, prevention measures, and limit-capped benefit modules. Such modules already exist, albeit inconsistently – for example, additional costs for ecological restoration and energy consulting²⁰ or a dedicated sustainability module in residential building insurance²¹.
    • Motor (Standard 423): Drivetrain type, battery condition, charging infrastructure, telematics, and claims settlement using recycled parts.
    • Life and Health (Standards 422 and 424): Taxonomy-compliant investment criteria and preventive health factors, structured as cover or clause. For the investment side, BiPRO should build a bridge to the EET, which already comprises 600+ data fields²².

    References

    Much sustainability data originates outside insurance and is maintained there. The data model should be able to reuse these sources.

    • Buildings: Article 22 of the EU Energy Performance of Buildings Directive obliges every member state to set up a national database for the overall energy performance of buildings²³; the implementation deadline expired on 29 May 2026. In Germany, it is still under construction²⁴. Referencing a building ID or energy certificate will avoid re-capturing data in future.
    • Batteries: From 18 February 2027, the digital battery passport becomes mandatory for EV batteries, e-bikes, and industrial batteries above 2 kWh²⁵. The passport ID can link motor, home contents, and building policies with verified data.
    • Terms and conditions: GDV clauses already exist for many modules, such as PK 7367 regarding additional costs for voluntary energy-efficiency modernisation²⁶. These can be referenced directly as codelist entries.
    • Claims remediation: With VdS 6038, GDV and VdS have formulated sustainability targets for property damage remediation as a non-binding industry standard²⁷. A standard can also refer to this instead of inventing its own criteria.

    Versioned and Verifiable

    Two characteristics make the data model future-proof.

    First, each category carries a reference to the regulatory framework under which it was assigned – SFDR in its old or new version, future rules for non-life. Regulation changes; the data model must not break every time it does.

    Second, every feature carries an audit reference. Since the update to the UWG, blanket environmental claims without proof are prohibited. A policy calling itself "sustainable" therefore needs verifiable individual features – and that is precisely what a typed data model delivers.

    What Needs to Change Between Broker and Insurer

    The process follows the data model, not vice versa. Once the ESG data object is defined, steps along the entire value chain change:

    1. Advice. The customer's preference becomes a standalone, structured object: category, topics, weighting, timestamp. The default value is "neutral" – as EIOPA already prescribes for insurance-based investment products when a customer expresses no sustainability preference²⁹. If no product matches the stated preference, the deviation is documented with a justification.

    2. Quote and Application (TAA). The result of the matching process is transmitted alongside the application. This embeds the advice record directly into the application journey – a point EY highlighted shortly after the introduction of the IDD requirement as a prerequisite for distribution rollout³⁰.

    3. In-force / Portfolio (Standard 430.4). The indicators fixed in the application must flow consistently back into broker management software and distribution systems – not just once, but with every event that alters the policy status: energy retrofitting, adding natural hazard cover, or recategorising a fund under SFDR 2.0. Only then can the broker see whether a policy still aligns with their client's preferences and react accordingly.

    4. Claims. The mode of settlement becomes a verifiable feature: repair, re-used parts, drying, "build back better". The industry is further along here than with products – according to VdS 6038, 81 percent of the market considers sustainability criteria in their processes, and 71 percent focus on repair rather than replacement²⁷. What is missing is the structured feedback loop of this information into the policy.

    5. Reporting as a by-product. If prevention features, climate coverages, and settlement types exist in a structured format, the taxonomy share of premiums and data for PCAF calculations can be derived from the portfolio instead of being compiled manually every year.

    Outlook: Will the Green Virtuous Circle Materialise?

    A virtuous circle initiated by end customers out of conviction is rather unlikely in P&C insurance.

    Intent is present, execution is not. According to Q-Perior, 58 percent of insurance customers would pay more for sustainable products, with parents under 40 willing to pay 15 percent more on average³¹. At the same time, according to a study by FH Dortmund, 40 percent deprioritise sustainability as long as prices rise³². Market researchers estimate that only 30 to 50 percent of declared intentions actually translate into purchasing behaviour³³.

    Other markets demonstrate what works. Organic food sales reached a record €18.23 billion in 2025, yet market share stands at just 6.5 percent³⁴. The key growth drivers were retailer private-label organic brands³⁵ – sustainability on standard shelves at standard prices. Bain also notes that people act sustainably without calling it that: 48 percent of AI users have already used AI to live more sustainably, and 41 percent use product information apps³⁶.

    A vision for P&C insurance. Sustainability becomes a by-product of good data. Premium structures automatically reward behaviour – based on verified data from energy performance certificates, battery passports, prevention measures, and sensor technology rather than an attitude survey. The customer's AI agent queries policy attributes electronically and filters according to their preferences; providers failing to deliver structured attributes remain invisible to it. The broker transforms into a resilience coach. And claims handling closes the loop: repair or sustainable restoration is actively managed, with proof flowing back into the policy record.

    In this way, a green virtuous circle can emerge: structured data makes sustainability visible in comparisons; at equal prices, it sways decision-making; volume encourages insurers to build further modules; rating agencies turn it into a criterion – and regulation builds upon an established standard. The end result is something like a product passport for insurance policies, made transparent and traceable via BiPRO standards and processes.

    Conclusion

    Investment products first created obligations and only later delivered data – with well-known consequences for advice. P&C insurance can flip the script and get ahead of the curve using BiPRO standards.

    The real lever lies not in sustainability reporting, but in the data flows between customer, broker, insurer, and service provider: preferences, prevention and geodata, lifecycle events, and settlement types.

    A typed, versioned, and verifiable data model makes sustainability audit-proof – for brokers, comparison engines, AI agents, and regulators alike. The fact that BiPRO e.V. is now tackling this issue is an important signal. Those who standardise the data first will set the tempo before obligations arrive.

    Podcast on this article

    There is also a podcast episode with Andreas & Annika on this article — we discuss the topics in more depth. Listen right here:

    00:0000:00
    Standard & Signal Podcast
    Downloads for this article

    The materials for this article are available for free in the reader portal.

    • Sources10 November 202634 KB

      Quellenverzeichnis – Greensurance braucht Struktur: Warum nachhaltige Versicherung bei normierten Datenflüssen beginnt

      quellenverzeichnis-greensurance-braucht-struktur-bipro.pdf

      Sachliches Quellenverzeichnis zum Fachbeitrag über normierte ESG-Datenflüsse, BiPRO-Integration und nachhaltige Versicherungs-IT in der Sachversicherung.

    • Presentation10 November 2026416 KB

      Präsentation (PDF) – Greensurance braucht Struktur: Warum nachhaltige Versicherung bei normierten Datenflüssen beginnt

      praesentation-greensurance-bipro-datenfluesse.pdf

      Erfahren Sie, wie normierte BiPRO-Datenflüsse und ein strukturiertes ESG-Datenmodell nachhaltige Versicherungsprozesse in der Sachversicherung ermöglichen.

    Free access via the newsletter

    Sign up for the newsletter and get access to all downloads and presentations for this article in the reader portal.